Fantasy, New Adult Romance

My Review: House of Sky and Breath (Crescent City #2): by Sarah J. Maas

Publish Date: February 15th, 2022
Number of Pages: 805 pages
Publisher: Bloomsbury
Genre(s): Fantasy, New Adult Romance

***Warning! This book review contains spoilers for this book and the previous book in the series, so continue reading at your own risk! You’ve officially been warned***

To see my review of book #1 – House of Earth and Blood – Click HERE

To see my Fancast/Dreamcast of the series – Click HERE

Total Star Rating: 4.75 Stars

His smile broadened as he walked out. ‘I never would have met Bryce. And every horror, every nightmare … all of it had been worth it for her.’

– Sarah J. Maas, “House of Sky and Breath”

What It’s About:

The official synopsis:

Bryce Quinlan and Hunt Athalar are trying to get back to normal―they may have saved Crescent City, but with so much upheaval in their lives lately, they mostly want a chance to relax. Slow down. Figure out what the future holds.

The Asteri have kept their word so far, leaving Bryce and Hunt alone. But with the rebels chipping away at the Asteri’s power, the threat the rulers pose is growing. As Bryce, Hunt, and their friends get pulled into the rebels’ plans, the choice becomes clear: stay silent while others are oppressed, or fight for what’s right. And they’ve never been very good at staying silent.

In this sexy, action-packed sequel to the #1 bestseller House of Earth and Blood, Sarah J. Maas weaves a captivating story of a world about to explode―and the people who will do anything to save it.

~~~

Okay, so it’s only been about a month and I think I NOW can say I’ve gathered my thoughts on this book that has actually stolen my breath away! This was easily one of my most anticipated book releases of 2022 since its been two years since we’ve ventured with these characters and experienced all that happens in House of Earth and Blood.

It’s quite the sequel to say the least! Old characters get new depths added to them, there’s a plethora of new characters who add so much to the story, there’s tons and tons of twists and turns, the plot somehow gets deeper and deeper, and lets just say that ending will freakin’ BLOW YOUR MIND like it did more me at 2 in the morning!

In this book, the story starts up again a few months after the catastrophic events where the glass gates are opened with portals to Hel and the demons are let loose in the city and countless people are injured or killed. Bryce and Hunt are just trying to ignore the thinly veiled threat of the overruling Asteri and their watchful eyes, and are just trying to live their normal lives and continue to be together under more mundane and normal circumstances. Things aren’t that easy, as they learn about rebel movements in place and secret weapons being found that could turn the tides of this possible war on the horizon (lets be real, we know it’s happening, has it never actually happened in a fantasy book you’ve read?)

This is also quite a substantial book and is easily one of her thickest titles to date, but it doesn’t feel that way as you read it; she has this way of connecting you to all her characters in such a way that you could literally read them talking over sports while drinking in a bar and you won’t get bored.

Speaking of the characters, that is such a major highlight of this book! Characters you met in the original book are back and have so much added onto them as the story develops that they still feel so fresh and real, even though you may not like as many of them as you get to know them! I don’t remember the last time I was so jealous of a character being surrounded by so many amazing male characters, but here Bryce is with company like Hunt, Ruhn, Ithan, Tharion, Flynn, Declan, and even a new character who is a lot more than meets the eye!

Thats the other thing about the new characters: there’s a lot of them, and ALL of them serve a huge purpose to the story and the many twists and reveals that come your way! I love the cast so much, and no surprise, SJM has truly created a wonderful array of them for us to enjoy.

One thing I can definitely critique is that we were promised a lot more spice in this book….first of all, I wasn’t a fan of the idea of Hunt and Bryce keeping things slow and trying things out on a platonic level–a horrible decision, really–and I thought we were promised like 500% more sex in this book! Well technically there’s more sex in this book than the previous one, but the amount we were promised sounds like there was supposed to be even more than what we got in A Court of Silver Flames…I’m not saying we don’t get any, we do and it’s great and it makes me happy when they go at it, but I was hoping for more in this regard.

And of course that ending……..oh my goodness, I can’t say any more because I risk spoiling it, but just holy shit that has to be the best way to end this book or any of her books! I need another SJM new release NOW!

I say anyone who sticks with the series all ADORE this book, it’s so much better in every way, I wish I could sound like I wasn’t just gushing about this book, but when my only critique was that there wasn’t enough spice in it, it’s hard not to! This book was phenomenal!!

Males will always try to control the females who scare them. Marriage and breeding are their go-to methods.

– Sarah J. Maas, “House of Sky and Breath”

What I Liked:

  1. THAT ENDING! I think I speak for the whole dang fandom when I say that the way this book ended was probably the most epic, most exciting, most mindfuckable of an ending that she could’ve come up with! I know It’s said a lot as we all finish books, but holy shitballs do I need the next book NOW!!!
  2. Things Get Spicier! Bryce and Hunt finally get their heads out of their own butts and into each others genitals! Yes, I went there…….but so did they *wink*wink*
  3. The Twists! Sarah J. Maas continues to surprise us readers to no end as more and more gets revealed! Danika and her extra-curricular activities that Bryce had no idea about, new characters who thicken the plot, Family tree’s revealed, The Underking, the Asteri, and even Hel itself and the Demon Princes have information all exposed about them that really raise the stakes! Plus, ALL the new characters have so much to add to the story in different ways, like there wasn’t one random addition, and they all had more going on beneath the surface to make this book even more addictive…
  4. The Multiple Romances! In Book 1, the romance was definitely all about Hunt and Bryce, and while it still shines a light on their relationship plenty, there were some other relationships also formed! Some were more alliances, but for some male characters, there’s definitely some sparks (or flames) flying!
  5. Buddy Reading It With My #Bookstagram Friends! I joined Bookstagram back in October, and I’ve made some truly wonderful friends while being active on there! We finally did our first successful buddy read together with this book, and it was so much fun to come up with theories and guess who was behind the many mysteries that raised questions, and of course, gush about the sex scenes! Brit, Kay, Laura, and Emily – Nothing But Love for my Wolfpack ❤

What I Didn’t Like:

  1. Where’s The Smut?…So yeah there are sex scenes that finally happen in this book, but weren’t we promised like 500% more sex in this book? Umm, I think the decimal should’ve been moved over a few spots…I mean, there was so much sex in A Court of Silver Flames that some got cut out! What we got between Hunt and Bryce (and even Ruhn a few times) was hot and spicy like how I like my food, but with the promise of more, I felt like the quantity didn’t meet expectations.
  2. Tharion Was Pretty Shady…I love mermaids, and especially hot mermen, but Tharion was making some questionable decisions in this book, and exhibited some less than stellar behavior, like I was finding myself not happy with him and some of the things he did. Just shady behavior…..
  3. All The Tightening Balls…Laura in my Bookstagram Wolfpack pointed this out so then I couldn’t not notice this, but when SJM was writing about a male getting turned on, several times there was a mention of his balls tightening in arousal….LET ME tell you all who read this that this does not happen, if anything we get a hard-on, but our balls don’t tighten except for if we’re freakin’ freezing and the temperature is dangerously low…so not hot, no pun intended. Women authors who say this in romance/erotica need to cease and desist!
  4. The Book Got Spoiled Before It’s Release Date…Now this doesn’t affect my overall rating of how much I enjoyed this book, but all I can say is there’s a special place in Hel for those who leaked the book and gave major spoilers before the book even released is unforgivable! Some A-holes even tried to sell books from BAM (Books A Million) a week early for well over $100 dollars…I hate people sometimes.

Conclusion:

Overall, House of Sky and Breath exceeded expectations of how this story continues, there’s hardly a bad thing I can say about it. The world-building continues, there’s no info dumping like in book #1, the romance was much more present and was with more characters besides just Hunt and Bryce: Ruhn even has a little something something happening on his end too!

The ending of this book is quite literally mind-blowing, and like I said before, I am in desperate need of a new SJM book like NOW, I hope we don’t have to wait years for any answers to what I saw as the final scene in this wonderful book.

It’s by far the best book of 2022 for me so far, I’m so looking forward to how this story keeps developing! its ahhhh-mazing

Thanks for Reading!

— Nick Goodsell

Fancasts/Dreamcasts

My Fancast/Dreamcast: The Crescent City Series by Sarah J. Maas

Image from my bookstagram account: @goodyreads

*Updated as of March 2025*

In the start of a brand new ADULT fantasy series by one of my favorite authors, we are once again introduced to an astounding cast of characters in another richly detailed world created by one of the Queens of YA Fantasy. This book just released earlier in 2020, so of course I wanted to share my own personal fancast of this book that I’d devoured since I’d opened it’s pages.

Here’s the official blurb:

Bryce Quinlan had the perfect life—working hard all day and partying all night—until a demon murdered her closest friends, leaving her bereft, wounded, and alone. When the accused is behind bars but the crimes start up again, Bryce finds herself at the heart of the investigation. She’ll do whatever it takes to avenge their deaths.

Hunt Athalar is a notorious Fallen angel, now enslaved to the Archangels he once attempted to overthrow. His brutal skills and incredible strength have been set to one purpose—to assassinate his boss’s enemies, no questions asked. But with a demon wreaking havoc in the city, he’s offered an irresistible deal: help Bryce find the murderer, and his freedom will be within reach.

As Bryce and Hunt dig deep into Crescent City’s underbelly, they discover a dark power that threatens everything and everyone they hold dear, and they find, in each other, a blazing passion—one that could set them both free, if they’d only let it.

With unforgettable characters, sizzling romance, and page-turning suspense, this richly inventive new fantasy series by #1 New York Times bestselling author Sarah J. Maas delves into the heartache of loss, the price of freedom—and the power of love.

To see my review of book #1 – House of Earth and Blood Click HERE

To see my review of book #2 – House of Sky and Breath – Click HERE

~~~

Here is my official Fancast/Dreamcast:

~~~

Danika Fendyr: Elle Evans

Image courtesy of marriedbiography.com

Elle is a model/actress that I came across during my search for some cute blondes; I guess she’s most notably from Robin Thicke’s “Blurred Lines” music video.

~~~

Jesiba Roga: Evan Rachel Wood

Image courtesy of the actress’s IMDB profile

Evan Rachel Wood is an absolute show-stealer in HBO’s “Westworld,” and when I’d read Jesiba’s description in the book, Evan immediately came to mind, especially when I remembered her wearing this look to the Golden Globes in recent memory.

~~~

Connor Holstrom: Stephen Amell

Credit to owner

Stephen Amell has the perfect look for the second in command of Danika’s pack. For any of you DC/Marvel fans, Stephen has recently finished his most notable role from the CW’s “Arrow.” Despite how the book plays out, I really did wish Bryce and Connor could’ve had a chance.

~~~

Ithan Holstrom: Robbie Amell

Image courtesy of tvovermind.com

Ithan is Connor’s younger brother in this story, so why not get Stephen Amell’s cousin to play the role? I’ve been in love with Robbie ever since he played Max in Disney Channel’s Life With Derek, and he’s been in The Babysitter, The DUFF, and the CW’s The Flash.

~~~

Thorne: Steve Lund

Image courtesy of http://www.stevelund.net

Danika also had a chance at happiness with Thorne, who was a quieter member of their pack. He didn’t say much, but Steve came to mind of who I’d thought he’d looked like. Steve has been in the shows Bitten, Schitts Creek, and even had a brief appearance in Blue Mountain State.

~~~

Sabine Fendyr: Madchen Amick

Image courtesy of the actress’s Twitter profile

I absolutely adore her as Alice Cooper in the CW’s hit show, Riverdale, and thought of her when I’d gotten to meet Danika’s absolutely despicable mother.

~~~

Fury Axtar: Gemma Chan

Image courtesy of fashiongonerogue.com

Gemma has such striking features; she’s stuck with me ever since I’d seen her in Crazy Rich Asians. Looking at Sarah J. Maas’s Pinterest board for the book, I learned the mercenary/assassin was of Eastern Asian descent, so of course I’d think Gemma would be a great Fury!

~~~

Juniper Andromeda: Lea Mitchell

She’s another WWE wrestling fancast, but seriously SOOOOO perfect to play Juniper!!! She goes under the ring-name “Kelani Jordan.”

~~~

Isaiah Tiberian: Elliot Knight

Image courtesy of the actor’s Twitter profile

He played Merlin in ABC’s Once Upon a Time, and also briefly appeared in How To Get Away with Murder. Feel free to check him out on social media and see his bromance with bestselling LGBTQ YA author, Adam Silvera too!

~~~

Viktoria Vargos: Jenna Dewan

Image courtesy of rebeccanorinne.com

The former Mrs. Channing Tatum, who is an actress and dancer, has been around dance all her life and has been linked to several big names in the music industry before she starred in the 2006 dance flick, Step Up.

~~~

Ruhn Danaan: Fabien Tietjen

Credit to owner

Ruhn was by far was the hardest to find someone to cast…he’s got such unique look to him! Odds are whoever would plays him will be spending A LOT of time in make-up to get the look of the Fae Prince. Fabien is a German model, and he defs rocks the blue eyed tattooed look, and with a long wig, he’d look quite like Ruhn in my opinion!

~~~

Naomi Borgeas: Tessa Thompson

Image courtesy of fashiongonerogue.com

Badass female character who’s a POC…it almost goes without saying that Tessa Thompson is made for that role!

~~~

Justinian: Harry Lloyd

Image courtesy of theapricity.com

This one is still kind of up in the air for me to be honest…

~~~

Lehabah: Lizzo

Image courtesy of affinitymagazine.com

This is a match made in heaven…the famous music artist would make an amazing firesprite who’s all about the latest gossip and the hottest males who enter Bryce’s life. I just pictured this character being more curvy and similar to Lizzo’s figure.

~~~

The Autumn King” Einar Danaan: Viggo Mortensen

Image courtesy of http://www.fanpop.com

It’s hard to imagine Viggo playing such a prick of a character like the High Fae Autumn King, especially since he’s frickin’ Aragorn in The Lord of the Rings movies. I know he’s a terrific actor, and I’d want him to try this completely different role than the one I’m so used to seeing him as.

~~~

The Viper Queen: Lourdes Faberes

Image courtesy of the actress’s IMDB profile

I’d recently watched the mini-series Good Omens, and really enjoyed seeing her play one of the four horsemen of the apocalypse, Pollution, and think she’d also crush the role of the sketchy drug dealer in Crescent City.

~~~

Philip Briggs: Michael McElhatton

Credit to owner

He played the slimy and deceptive Roose Bolton in Game of Thrones, so I’d think he’d play the human terrorist/rebel who has had unspeakable terrors happen to him behind bars.

~~~

Micah Domitus: Casper Van Dien

Image courtesy of the actor’s IMDB profile

I know him best from the Starship Troopers movies that were so bad that they were actually good, but he’s got such a commanding look; he’d be able to nail the powerful role of the governor who hardly takes “no” for an answer.

~~~

Tristan Flynn: Hunter McVey

Image courtesy of the model’s Instagram

To be honest, I don’t remember much that was said about his appearance, but if Tristan is such a big flirt, he’s got to have the looks to back it up, right? Hunter, without a question, can step up to the plate.

~~~

Declan Emmett: Finn Jones, or Nico Greetham

Finn, Image courtesy of Entertainment Weekly
Nico, image courtesy of pop-culturist

Another Game of Thrones alumni, Finn Jones went from playing a Tyrell to being Danny Rand on Iron Fist. Nico actually was in American Horror Story if he looks familiar!

~~~

Sandriel: Evangeline Lilly

Image courtesy of http://www.99starimages.com

Evangeline is so beautiful, it’s intimidating…she can kick some serious ass as an elf in The Hobbit movies, and is also a part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe in Ant-Man alongside Paul Rudd. I think the bombshell would have no problem playing the ruthless and powerful governess of the northern region of Pangera.

~~~

Tharion Ketos: Austin Zenere, or Callum Kerr

Austin, Credit to owner

Austin is a model, and Tharion is an extremely good looking mermaid…so it’s pretty much an easy set up there, right? I really hope we see more of Tharion and the other merpeople in the later books! Callum is a Scottish actor and model I’ve recently discovered who could definitely play the part!

~~~

Ember Quinlan: Rose Byrne

Image courtesy of celebmafia.com

Ember was the perfect combination of funny but protective whenever it came to her daughter, Byrce. I feel like Rose Byrne would be perfect to play her, I pretty much love every movie she’s in!

~~~

Randall Quinlan: Don Cheadle

Image courtesy of Variety Magazine

Don Cheadle is extremely versatile as an actor; he can be serious in movies like Hotel Rwanda and Crash, but can show his comedy skills when he joined the MCU. Randall is the kind of father that can joke around one moment, but can become hardass, military dad with excessive intimidation in his arsenal the next.

~~~

Aidas: Neels Visser

Image courtesy of avemanagement.com

Perhaps the most interesting character in the whole book, the 5th Demon Prince leaves quite an impression, and must be as striking as he is chilling. Neels is a model and actor who’s VERY easy on the eyes, so can he manage to cast the perfect amount of wickedness as his character? I’d like to watch to find out!

~~~

Amelie Ravenscroft: Taylor Grado

Another WWE fancasting here, she’s a female wrestler that goes under the ring name “Jacy Jayne” and totally matches the vibe of how I pictured Amelie in these books!

~~~

Pollux Antonius: Alan Ritchson

This guy somehow makes Henry Cavill look puny….and he played the iconic Thad Castle! Now he’s Jack Reacher, and someone who I can totally picture as Sandriel’s commander of the triarii, the Malleus, and master of torture.

~~~

Queen Hypaxia Enador: Shay Mitchell

Image courtesy of http://www.gotceleb.com

Shay Mitchell is a favorite of mine ever since I’d first laid eyes on her in the hit TV show, Pretty Little Liars. She then completely switched up her character to play Peaches Salinger in the (now) Netflix show You. She has such a unique look, I’m a big fan, and I’d love to have her be a part of this casting!

~~~

Sofie Renast: Daniella Pineda

image courtesy of her IMDB profile

You may recognize her from the very early episodes of The Originals!

~~~

Lidia Cervos “The Hind”: Sydney Zmrzel

image courtesy of WWE

The Hind is described as being one of the most beautiful women in this world, and Sydney came to mind as I am an avid WWE wrestling fan, and she portrays “Maxxine Dupri” on my screen on a weekly basis!

~~~

Prince Cormac Donnall: Austin Butler

Austin Butler has quickly become a household name in the last few years with the impressive list of movies he’s been a part of! It’s so weird to think that he started off as a Disney Channel one episode add on for shows in the mid 2000’s

~~~

Archangel Governess Celestina: Sanaa Lathan, or Gabrielle Union

Sanaa, image courtesy not available
Gabrielle Union, image courtesy of shape.com

I could honestly see either of these actress’s play the new governess of Lunathion after the demise of the previous one! Celestina was an interesting character because even though she was kind and fair, I still couldn’t figure out if I could trust her…leave it to SJM to make me question an actually nice person of a character!

~~~

Baxian Argos “The Hellhound”: Keith Carlos

Image courtesy of courant.com

Yet another character who ends up being way more than their first impression fortells! I ended up really liking Baxian and am curious to see what else he does in the series! Keith Carlos is a former NFL wide receiver and now male model who was actually the first male winner of America’s Next Top Model!

~~~

Mordoc: Dolph Lundgren

Image courtesy of npr.org

Dolph Lundgren is a famous actor who was in quite a bit of action movies in the 80’s, but even was in The Expendables with a notable list of other action movie stars from different generations! He’s also been in Creed II, Rocky IV, and I believe he would be an excellent choice for this terrifying character in book 2!

~~~

“The Harpy”: Riley Keough

Image courtesy of nytimes.com

For some reason I pictured the granddaughter of Elvis Presley playing this minor character who’s temper is about a sharp as an actual harpy eagle’s talons!

~~~

Archangel Ephraim: Oscar Isaac

Image courtesy of wallpaperfire.com

Oscar Isaac is who I imagined this character being, the Star Wars actor has this presence and authority vibe that I picked up from this character!

~~~

Asteri “Bright Hand,” Rigelus: Timothée Chalamet

Image courtesy of theverge.com

The Bright Hand (and unofficial leader) of the Asteri is described as being a lanky teenager with a chilling smile….Timothée instantly came to mind. It’s hard to think of anyone who doesn’t know this young actor’s name or face by now, his star power has certainly risen to astronomical heights with him starring in Dune–what may have been the most anticipated film I can remember in a long time!

~~~

Marc Rosarian: Jeremy Pope

Image courtesy of the actor’s IMDB profile

Here’s who I picture as Declan’s boyfriend! He’s a gay actor/model/singer who I think would be perfect for the part!

~~~

Apollion: Joel Kinnaman

Image courtesy of the actor’s IMDB profile

Joel is a Swedish-American actor whom most people may recognize from the DC Suicide Squad movies and Altered Carbon on Netflix!

~~~

Thanatos: Bill Skarsgård

Image courtesy of USA Today

I feel like I hardly need to describe who Bill is, but he is easily the Hottie of Horror lately with Nosferatu and IT, and Thanatos gives me vibes that he’s the creepy brother of the Princes of Hel, so this may be a match made in heaven, okay yes pun intended.

~~~

Pippa Spestos: Lauren Cohan

Honestly Lauren is easily a go-to fancast choice for me ever since The Vampire Diaries…I make no apologies for this.

~~~

Ariadne: Simone Ashley, or Melissa Barrera

Simone, image courtesy of BBN Times
Melissa, image courtesy of Latin Times

Both actors would absolutely nail this fiery role in my opinion! Simone is the iconic Kate from Bridgerton on Netflix, and Melissa most notably from the two newest Scream movies before allegedly(?) being fired for her views on the Israel/Palestine War.

~~~

Captain Sendes: Ayo Edibri

Image courtesy of AP News

There’s not much description of Captain Sendes except for her dark skin, and I feel like Ayo, with her comedic chops, would breathe some more life into this minor character!

The Under King: Willem Dafoe

Image courtesy of Wikipedia

I feel like Willem would make the creepy Under King even more fabulously creepy with his facial expressions and just have so much fun with this character!

~~~

Vesperus: Mikey Madison

Image courtesy of Vogue

I was first introduced to her in the 5th Scream movie of all things, but then in 2025 she become the awards season darling it seemed like! She would crush this roll for sure! This character was super interesting when she showed up in Flame and Shadow!

~~~

Sathia Flynn: Addison Rae

Image courtesy of Forbes

Addison looks exactly like how I pictured Tristan’s sister looking, hopefully her acting improved from that He’s All That movie she did on Netflix though…

~~~

River Queen: Kerry Washington

Image courtesy of Getty Images

I’ve known about Kerry Washington for some time, but I recently watched her WW2 movie, The Six Triple Eight, on Netflix and loved it! I’ve been meaning to watch Scandal for the longest time too.

~~~

River Queen’s Daughter: Halle Bailey

Yes, my brain instantly went to this because of the live-action Little Mermaid that she absolutely crushed! And yes, it’s a completely different character than Ariel….and?

Sigril Fendyr: Camila Morrone

Image courtesy of Television Academy

This wild card character sure shook things up for the wolves in the third book, and this actress definitely looks like how I imagined this character!

~~~

Hunt Athalar: Colby Lopez, Antonio Moriconi, or Marino Katsouris

Colby, Image courtesy of wwe.com
Antonio, image courtesy of the models instagram
Marino, image courtesy of the model’s Facebook page

Colby Lopez is a WWE Superstar who goes by the name “Seth Rollins” when he get’s inside the ring, so besides the looks, he’d obviously be able to perform the more physically demanding stunts with playing the infamous fallen angel nicknamed the Umbra Mortis. Looking at Colby/Seth in 2025 with his….interesting fashion choices, I he doesn’t really give me Hunt Athalar vibes like he used to from like 2017-2019, so these models I found are great alternatives I think!

~~~

Bryce Quinlan: Natalie Marie Nelson

Image courtesy of the actress’s Twitter account

Natalie is a gorgeous actress/reality tv star who is most well known for when she was in the WWE and E!’s reality show “Total Divas”, under the ring name “Eva Marie.” Her hair is no longer red, but look her up and see for yourself how amazing she’d look the part!

~~~

:: More Characters to be added as the series goes on! ::

Thanks for Reading!

— Nick Goodsell